About games and gaming thereof!

id Software Hoedown

Thanks to the Steam Summer sale I now have all of the Doom and Quake games, excluding Quake 4. I’m not sure how interested people are in my whole new-retro shtick, but I figure I might as well talk about them since I’ve been playing them a lot lately. I don’t have enough to say to warrant a post for each individual game, but if I bundle my thoughts on all the games into one post I’m sure it can work.


I’m aware that Doom is one of the first FPS games ever made, and I must say that I’m quite impressed. The combat works well and has a decent flow to it. The levels are big and sprawling, and praise be to Odin, there’s actually an intuitive map you can look at. The guns actually feel fairly different from one another, and the monsters have enough variety to prevent it from feeling too repetitive.

I played Duke Nukem 3D a few months back via Good Old Games, and I detested it. I assumed that was because I just couldn’t get into the whole “2.5D” thing, but that’s not the case, because I’ve been enjoying Doom 1 quite a lot. No, the real reason I didn’t like Duke was because the controls were very clunky.

The story for Doom appears to be pretty much nonexistent. “Baddies over there, go kill them” seems to be the gist of it. I’m cool with that. To me, the story in a game is basically like the lyrics in a song. It can add more entertainment value to the whole package if it’s done well, but it’s not really necessary.

On the whole, I like Doom. I like it a lot. And I think I’m gonna play it some more once I’m done writing this.


Refer to above comments concerning Doom 1.

Seriously, it’s the same game. It’s an expansion pack, that’s what it is. More of the same gameplay in different environments with different monsters. Really not much to say about it.


Now here’s where things change. Doom 3 was released long, long after Doom 1, and while the weapons and monsters are basically the same, the overall feel is very different. While Doom 1 is a game about intense, balls-to-the-wall action, Doom 3 tries to go for subtle, claustrophobic horror. And it kind of fails in that regard. It’s a bit scary at first, but it’s the same problem I had with FEAR 2, it’s just too repetitive.

And this game also has a serious problem with lighting. So many areas are covered in darkness, and you can’t use a flashlight with your gun; you have to pull out a flashlight just to see what’s going on, which breaks up the flow of combat. I get that they were trying to show off their whole dynamic lighting technology, but it just gets annoying after awhile.

Doom 3 has much bigger production values than Doom 1, and it certainly looks better, but on the whole I just don’t find it as engaging. I have to agree with the others who say that Serious Sam is the true successor to Doom 2.

Though it is worth mentioning that the very, very beginning of the game is really interesting. There are no monsters, and you walk through the space station and get to see the marines at work. It reminds me of the intro to Half-Life 1 in a good way.


Quake will always hold a special place in my heart, because when I close my eyes and try to remember the first shooter I ever played, Quake is always the one that comes to mind. Of course I can’t remember it very well because I was so young at the time that the only memories I have now are tiny little glimpses, but I think the fact that I remember it at all shows that Quake had an impact on me as a child.

This game is an interesting specimen, because it seems to be right in the middle of the transitionary phase of first person shooters from 2D to 3D. The environments are rendered in full 3D, but the enemies are still in that awkward 2.5D state, so the game as a whole feels a bit weird.*

Aside from that, the controls feel fairly awkward since you can’t look up or down using the mouse, and the game is just too brown. The lack of contrast almost makes me feel nauseous when playing it. Seriously. When people complain about games these days being too brown it makes me wonder if they ever played Quake, because it puts any game made in the past decade or so to shame in terms of lack of color variety.

It’s interesting to play in a sort of historical sense (sorry if I just made you feel really old by saying that) but it just isn’t that much fun.

Quake 2

Okay, you’ve watched at least one episode of my LP of Unreal, right? Well then I don’t need to say anything about Quake 2 because it’s the same fucking game.

Okay, so maybe Quake 2 is fairly more linear and brown than Unreal, but other than that it feels exactly the same. Same alien baddies, same guns, same early 3D FPS style gameplay. Really not much to say about it at this point.

Quake 3 Arena

Apparently Quake 3 is entirely multiplayer, which means I’m not gonna mess with it. I’m not much of a competitive shooter person, and whenever I do get that itch I have Team Fortress 2 to scratch it. Not to mention the fact that none of my friends have Quake 3, and I don’t know if I’d even be able to find anyone online to play with. The Steam summer sale has given me a virtual pile of games to play, so I’m gonna hold off on Quake 3 for now.


It’s nice to sample some more of gaming history, and it’s even nicer to have fun while doing so.

I guess all there’s left for me to play from id Software is Wolfenstein 3D. How about that, Steam? You still have one more day of summer sales left…

*UPDATE: That one paragraph about Quake was flat-out incorrect. Sorry about that.


10 responses

  1. Ranneko

    With regard to Qukae, you can look up and down with the mouse, it is just not a setting. The console command +mlook is what you are after.

    I agree that Doom 2 really is just a very big expansion to Doom 1, but that is only looking back on it. At the time I was delighted at the idea of the new enemies and the new gun.

    July 10, 2011 at 9:50 PM

    • JPH

      Ahh, that helps a lot, thanks. I need to learn to mess with console commands more.

      July 11, 2011 at 7:34 PM

  2. I don’t really get what you saying that Quake had 2.5D enemies. It was the first FPS that fully in 3D, including enemies.

    July 12, 2011 at 12:56 PM

    • JPH

      Are you sure we’re thinking of the same game? The monsters don’t look like 3D models to me, they look like 2D sprites.

      July 12, 2011 at 3:26 PM

    • JPH

      Wait, yeah, you’re right. I’m an idiot.

      The reason I thought they were 2D sprites is because their animations are so choppy and rigid that they felt reminiscent of the Doom baddies. But when you look at an unmoving enemy from different angles it’s pretty clear that yeah, it’s a 3D model. Just a very primitive one.

      July 12, 2011 at 3:40 PM

  3. Eldiran

    It sounds like you’re using the default controls for Duke Nukem, which are impossible to muddle through. However, you can change the controls almost 100% in the config program and the game suddenly becomes playable.

    July 13, 2011 at 8:27 AM

    • JPH

      I tried changing the controls in the config program, but for some reason it never works. The Duke Nukem program seems screwy all around; for some reason it won’t work if I just double-click the file, for some reason I have to specifically tell it to “Run as Administrator.”


      July 14, 2011 at 2:55 AM

  4. Eldiran

    Ah, that’s unfortunate. Perhaps someday you can get it to work… in fact, I’m noticing now that Duke Nukem doesn’t work at all on my new computer. Seems it only functions nicely on 32-bit systems.

    July 14, 2011 at 8:01 AM

  5. Sumanai

    “To me, the story in a game is basically like the lyrics in a song.”

    That’s a pretty apt simile in my opinion. It goes far too, since some seem to believe that lyrics are necessary, or that a song is automatically improved if lyrics are added.

    July 14, 2011 at 9:05 AM

    • JPH

      Yeah, it’s pretty uncanny how much the comparison fits, isn’t it? I don’t remember when I first thought of the analogy but I’ve always kept it in mind.

      July 17, 2011 at 4:27 PM

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s